Small Island Steakhouse
Our Story
Our Story
For many years we have dreamed and discussed operating a family run business. Now we have Broil, an intimate steak and seafood house.
We pride ourselves with excellent quality and service. Along with our extensive wine list, we offer domestic beers and a selection of craft beers.
We sincerely hope you have a lovely evening with us.
- The Weiss Family
Our mission is to bring an unforgettable memory of superb service and food to your Keys' experience.
Our mission is to bring an unforgettable memory of superb service and food to your Keys' experience.
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
"Absolutely the best restaurant in all the Keys. Worth the drive. Beautiful space, amazing staff, and the food- SPEECHLESS!"
≋Cara Oyster≋
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
Wow. Everything is presented beautifully and the food is some of the best I've ever had. Just wow.
≋Pierce≋
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
"From the moment we arrived, we were treated like family. The food! my GOD the food!
The owner, Brad, came over to greet us and check on us, as he did with everyone.
The best service we've ever had!"
≋Rachel Black≋
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
"My fiancé and I ate at BROIL a week ago. It was a fabulous environment and the service was outstanding. Everything we ate was so flavorful. We had the filet and lobster which was to die for. The salad was a lovely presentation and tasty as were the sides and can I tell you, the rosemary bread was grilled OMG was it delicious. A definite new favorite."
≋Linda Fountain≋
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
"Staff and services were top notch! Everyone was extremely friendly and welcoming. The decor and ambiance made it very romantic and upscale feeling but the prices were reasonable and the food...was OUTSTANDING! I had the strip steak, I was skeptical about the strip because I'm a ribeye guy but the steak was absolutely incredible. Perfectly tender and extremely flavorful."
≋John Maul≋
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
"We found Broil simply by accident as we were staying across the street. The food was amazing, and hands down the best we have ever had in the Keys! Steaks were cooked perfectly, the seafood was seasoned just right. Try the lobster potatoes and fried Brussels Sprouts and you won't be sorry. The entire staff was on point and the chef came out to say thank you. Just cannot give enough praise and we will definitely be back on our next trip to the area!"
≋Patty Wood≋
What Our Guests Are Saying...
What Our Guests Are Saying...
"HIGHLY RECOMMEND! The food was phenomenal!!! The staff/service was incredible! We will definitely return."
≋Lori Savory≋